Case file · Apparition · House or mansion

Hui Bon Hoa Mansion (Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts)

Also known as Nhà chú Hỏa, Dinh chú Hỏa, Bảo tàng Mỹ thuật TP.HCM, The ghost of the Fine Arts Museum

A 1930s mansion built for a wealthy Saigon Chinese-Vietnamese family, now the city’s art museum – and, rumour says, home to a hidden daughter’s ghost.

Hui Bon Hoa – known to Saigon as Chú Hỏa, born Huỳnh Văn Hoa – arrived from Fujian around 1863 and, according to the legends, started out collecting scrap bottles. His company became one of the great property empires of French Indochina, said to own many thousands of houses, and the family built or funded landmarks still standing today, including the Majestic Hotel and Từ Dũ maternity hospital. Chú Hỏa himself died in 1901 while visiting China, but his sons kept the business intact.

The yellow mansion at 97 Phó Đức Chính was designed by a French architect named Rivera and built between 1929 and 1934 for the family, in a blend of European and Chinese styles with walls up to 60 cm thick. Local lore says it was planned with a hundred doors, but the governor-general made the owners remove one so it would not outshine his palace – so it has ninety-nine. Since 1987 it has housed the Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts, with collections of lacquer painting, woodcuts and Cham sculpture.

As Saigon’s Sài Gòn Giải Phóng newspaper recounted in 2007, rumours that the house was haunted circulated well before 1975: people spoke of a white shape gliding along the corridors at night and of a ghost weeping. The most popular version, retold by Saigoneer in 2014, says the family’s only daughter fell ill with leprosy, was kept hidden in a closed room where servants passed food through a hatch, and died alone; her grief-stricken father had her placed in a stone coffin in the house, and her crying could still be heard. The story inspired a pre-1975 film, Con ma nhà họ Hứa (“The Ghost of the Hứa Family”), directed by Lê Mộng Hoàng.

No record supports the tale of a hidden daughter, and its usual form – with Chú Hỏa as the grieving father – is chronologically impossible, since he died nearly thirty years before the mansion was built. The legend also reflects the fear and stigma that once surrounded leprosy (Hansen’s disease), a curable illness whose patients were often isolated. Today the building is visited above all as one of Saigon’s finest colonial-era interiors.

What people report

Stories describe a white figure moving through the corridors and past windows after dark, a girl’s sobbing or screaming from an upper room, and – in some versions – a ghostly young woman in a white dress. Staff and visitors occasionally repeat the stories, but no documented incident has been reported.

Where and when

The upper floors and long corridors of the main building, and a room said to have been sealed, at night when the museum is closed.

Timeline of the haunting

  1. 1901
    The death of Chú Hỏa Fujian, China

    Hui Bon Hoa dies suddenly while visiting China with his wife and is buried there. His sons continue the family property company in Saigon.

  2. 1929–1934
    The mansion is built Saigon

    Architect Rivera’s design for the family’s mansion is completed on the block now bounded by Phó Đức Chính, Lê Thị Hồng Gấm, Calmette and Nguyễn Thái Bình streets.

  3. September 1987
    A museum of fine arts Ho Chi Minh City

    The building becomes the Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts, which opens fully to the public in the early 1990s.

  4. 14 May 2007
    “Legends of Chú Hỏa’s house” Ho Chi Minh City

    Sài Gòn Giải Phóng publishes a feature on the house’s legends, noting that ghost rumours predate 1975 and inspired a popular film.

  5. 8 May 2014
    Saigon Urban Legends Ho Chi Minh City

    Saigoneer retells the story of the hidden daughter for an English-language audience, spreading the legend to foreign visitors.

What could explain it?

  • The best-known version cannot be true as told, because Hui Bon Hoa died in 1901, decades before the mansion existed.
  • Wealthy, secretive families in grand houses have long attracted gossip; the hidden-invalid motif is a common ghost-story theme.
  • The legend draws on historic stigma about leprosy, when patients were often isolated from their communities.
  • A large, dim colonial building with long corridors and tall shuttered windows makes ordinary movements and sounds feel uncanny at night.

Ghost tours, books and screen

The legend inspired Lê Mộng Hoàng’s film Con ma nhà họ Hứa, one of the early Vietnamese ghost films, and it appears in Vietnamese ghost-story features and Saigon walking tours. The mansion is a favourite location for photo shoots and a symbol of the city’s Chinese-Vietnamese heritage.

Places to visit

Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts 97A Phó Đức Chính, District 1, Ho Chi Minh City

The city’s main art museum, set in the former Hui Bon Hoa mansion and two neighbouring buildings.

Where it’s reported

VietnamHo Chi Minh City

Hui Bon Hoa Mansion (Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts) in the news

No recent headlines about Hui Bon Hoa Mansion (Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts). Our news desk checks every day — see all the latest paranormal news.

Sources

  1. Sài Gòn Giải Phóng: Giai thoại nhà chú Hỏa (14 May 2007)
  2. Saigoneer (Dang Bui): Saigon urban legends – the ghost of the Fine Arts Museum (8 May 2014)
  3. Tuổi Trẻ: Từ nhà chú Hỏa đến Bảo tàng Mỹ thuật (16 September 2007)
  4. Vietnamese Wikipedia: Chú Hỏa
  5. Wikipedia: Ho Chi Minh City Museum of Fine Arts

First published · Updated